top of page

Suspension of Disbelief and the Nervous System

Oct 30
6 min read

“Role Boundary Blurring” or “Role Spill Over” are well-known terms describing what can happen to actors when they deeply immerse themselves in intense roles. Research describes how actors at times may develop feelings, beliefs and even physical symptoms that belong not to them but to their characters. Disturbed sleep or intrusive thoughts are also not uncommon after engaging with challenging performance content. Some studies have even observed long-term effects of role boundary blurring, resulting in confusion about the actor's sense of identity. [https://doi.org/10.1111/ap.12221 / https://eprints.bbk.ac.uk/id/eprint/52280/ / https://aura.antioch.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1560&context=etds]


With the performance industry becoming more aware of potential mental health risks, “De-rolling”, a process of coming out of a role and back to self, is an established practice recommended to actors for managing role boundary blurring.


During my recent research into how somatic therapeutic approaches might support actors’ nervous systems when working with sexual and violent material, I made a few interesting discoveries that may call for a rethink of how role boundary blurring is handled.


Acting, explored through the nervous system, is a fascinating phenomenon because of the concept of suspension of disbelief. This concept implies that blurring the boundaries between reality and fiction is not only something that can be problematic. It is also what makes performance magical. I further discovered that while everyone in the industry understands what de-rolling is, there is actually no agreement on how exactly it can be reliably achieved or how it can be most effective when considering the complexity of our nervous system.



The Magic Blur


One participant I interviewed described the magic of acting and storytelling as suspension of disbelief.


This phrase is often used to describe the audience's experience. We become emotionally invested in people who do not exist and events that never happened. Even our physiology responds to the make-believe with real startle, anxiety, anger, euphoria or relief. As Stephen Porges explains through Polyvagal Theory, while our cognitive brain holds the knowledge that what we are watching is not real, our autonomic nervous system is responding to the fiction as though it were real. Subsequently, our emotional and physical responses ARE real.


In order to give a believable performance, actors tend to participate at least temporarily in a version of the same process. An actor whose reflections formed part of the research described film as "hungering for a real event to happen". He spoke about actively attempting to generate genuine experience within himself, arguing that the camera is often not satisfied with the performance of emotion but demands something authentic.


Some may argue that the craft of acting is merely pretending, yet most of the time even pretending requires our nervous system to go through a somewhat real experience. In somatic therapy, at times, we also use the skill of imagination to create a real physical shift in the body. Acting utilises the same mechanism, often with the added bonus of interacting with co-performers and sets that will strengthen the conditions under which something subjectively real can occur.



The Relational Blur


What emerged in the research was that suspension of disbelief does not only affect audiences, and role boundary blurring does not only happen to actors.


Several participants described examples in which the emotional logic of a fictional story appeared to spill into real-world relationships, group dynamics and behaviours.


One intimacy coordinator described what frequently happened after filming scenes depicting sexual violence. Once filming stopped, crew members would instinctively rush to check on the actor who had played the victim. At the same time, the actor who had portrayed the perpetrator could find themselves standing alone and avoided by others.


Of course, nobody consciously believed a real assault had taken place. Yet people appeared to respond to the moral reality of the fictional narrative rather than the reality of the production process.


Another participant I interviewed shared that it seems the narrative created can spill somehow into the lives of anyone involved in the making of the fiction, as he explained: “Things will happen in your life and you have to remember that it’s the play.”


This suggests that role boundary blurring is not merely something that happens sometimes to an actor after an intense scene. It may also be something that affects the wider relational field and could be seen as the sometimes complicated, shadowy flipside to what we consider the very magic of performance.



The Problematic Blur


So role boundary blurring, by its very nature, is not necessarily evidence that something has gone wrong. In many ways, it may be evidence that the creative process has succeeded.

This may explain why some actors resist the idea of de-rolling because they fear disconnecting from their characters' reality and intensity. The same process that appears capable of causing distress is what is deemed to make the magic happen.


My research also showed that even when de-rolling is welcome, there appears to be no particular process for this or for how it is successfully achieved. As one of the participants described: “Whatever it might be, just do it mindfully, knowing that you are doing it to come back to yourself.”


The key seems to be to bring awareness to the transition between fiction and reality. Yet while many participants held the belief that the actor has their own process that is not to be questioned, one intimacy coordinator suggested that many actors actually do not understand what de-rolling really is and what it means.


Furthermore, Mark Seton brings the whole idea of de-rolling into question, as he argues that acting is far more complex than simply embodying another character that can be discarded at the end of the workday. "It is nonsense to speak of a character (...) as a material object that can be 'taken off' like a piece of clothing, or as something separate from the embodied life of a person in the context of performance" (https://doi.org/10.1386/peet.4.1.25_1).


The somewhat uncomfortable truth may be that a character comes alive and experiences its world through the body and nervous system of the actor. It does not exist in separation. It is not a costume we put on and off; it is something that emerges from and through the depth of a living being.



The Nervous System-Informed Blur


Rather than trying to simply disconnect from the fictional content, a nervous-system-informed approach might offer a specific emphasis on somatic literacy that can honour the complexity that is acting.


This literacy could support the performer in developing a more detailed and dynamic awareness of what is happening within them throughout the process. Ideally, others involved in the production process are also supported to hold this awareness for themselves to attend to the wider relational blur.


My research explored Peter Levine's SIBAM model, as described in his book In an Unspoken Voice, as one possible framework. Through tracking the elements of conscious experience: sensation, image, behaviour, affect and meaning, actors may develop a clearer sense of what belongs to their own experience and what has been activated in them through fiction. As one of my mentors, Betsy Polatin, says in her book The Actor’s Secret: "To understand another character, it makes sense for you first to understand your own" (p. 137).


On that strong foundation, the experiences the actor has through embodying a character can be identified and attended to.


This may involve noticing what remains activated after the scene is over. The SIBAM elements can be tracked and connected in order to explore what they relate to and what needs to happen for them to discharge. It may provide a framework to explore specific questions such as: Is there fear that still needs support? Anger that never got a chance to express? Tension that is still being carried because it was not able to complete an action? And, of course, not to forget: Are these activations relating to the fictional content, or has the fictional reality triggered something very real in the person’s history? Clarifying such questions may also help to identify when therapeutic support may become necessary.


From a somatic perspective, the task becomes less about removing the character and more about helping the nervous system process and complete what has been evoked through the performance. A detailed awareness of personal and character experiences in the body may not only give the actor insight into whether or not they are still carrying something that does not actually belong to them; it could also give them agency and the choice to decide what they actually want to hold on to for a bit longer, for the benefit of an upcoming scene, for example, while discharging what is problematic and no longer needed.



Let’s Master the Blur


The blur between fiction and reality is not simply a problem to be solved. It is a magical part of the artistic process, and it happens inside and between our bodies. Thinking about that, it is actually astonishing to me that so far there is very little awareness of autonomic nervous system function in the performance industry.


I believe that models like SIBAM and other approaches developed from what we have learned about our autonomic nervous system could allow performers, directors, educators, intimacy coordinators and productions to develop a more sophisticated understanding of what happens when fiction is experienced through a living body. It may empower those involved in this art form to expand what is possible while also keeping their nervous system safe. Perhaps it could be compared to playing a musical instrument and being able to learn how to play it with incredible nuance while never wearing out the instrument.


Comments


Address

Suite 6, 8 Madeira Ave.
Leigh on Sea, SS9 3EB

UK

Contact

Email: info@kristinloeer.com
Tel: 0044 07835 687719

Follow me

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Contact

Email: info@kristinloeer.com
Tel: 0044 07835 687719

Full Complimentary Therapist Association Membership

Follow me

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
UK Council for Psychotherapy Membership

Newsletter
sign up

Full Somatic Experiencing Association Membership 2026.png

© 2026 by Kristin Loeer - Somatic Psychotherapist

bottom of page